Polly’s guidebook
Food scene
(631) 899- 4646. This restaurant is relatively casual, and family and toddler friendly.
60 locals recommend
LT Burger
62 Main St(631) 899- 4646. This restaurant is relatively casual, and family and toddler friendly.
(631) 725 - 0900. This place attracts a younger crowd. But for an early dinner, especially outside, would be fine for a family including toddlers. They have a wood oven in which they make their own French bread, so I recommend the mussels, with the bread to soak up the sauce. I also recommend the pizzas.
63 locals recommend
Lulu Kitchen & Bar
126 Main St(631) 725 - 0900. This place attracts a younger crowd. But for an early dinner, especially outside, would be fine for a family including toddlers. They have a wood oven in which they make their own French bread, so I recommend the mussels, with the bread to soak up the sauce. I also recommend the pizzas.
(631) 725 - 1810. This restaurant is consistently good. One of my friends ordered their Prime NY strip, and said it was the best he had ever had. Their brunches are delicious and everything is fresh. This is not a glitzy restaurant and it does not “announce itself”. It just delivers excellent food, all the time.
40 locals recommend
Page at 63 Main
63 Main St(631) 725 - 1810. This restaurant is consistently good. One of my friends ordered their Prime NY strip, and said it was the best he had ever had. Their brunches are delicious and everything is fresh. This is not a glitzy restaurant and it does not “announce itself”. It just delivers excellent food, all the time.
(631) 259 - 2222. This is surprisingly good Indian Food, and is one of my favorites. It has many vegetarian options, and an early dinner would be toddler friendly. I tend to order the vegetarian, but I have been there with friends who have ordered the meat options, and they were very happy. The staff is also lovely, and if indoor dining is possible, the decor is simple and lovely.
19 locals recommend
Saaz
1746 County Rd 39(631) 259 - 2222. This is surprisingly good Indian Food, and is one of my favorites. It has many vegetarian options, and an early dinner would be toddler friendly. I tend to order the vegetarian, but I have been there with friends who have ordered the meat options, and they were very happy. The staff is also lovely, and if indoor dining is possible, the decor is simple and lovely.
(631) 725 - 3535. This is a classic, local place. The bar scene tends to be a more mature crowd. If you are here during scallop season, which is not until November, you have to at least go to the bar and order a small plate of their scallops. They are excellently prepared, in a sauce with some special ingredient that I have yet to discern. Maybe you can get one of the bartenders to fill you in.
124 locals recommend
American Hotel
45 Main St(631) 725 - 3535. This is a classic, local place. The bar scene tends to be a more mature crowd. If you are here during scallop season, which is not until November, you have to at least go to the bar and order a small plate of their scallops. They are excellently prepared, in a sauce with some special ingredient that I have yet to discern. Maybe you can get one of the bartenders to fill you in.
(631) 725 - 7009. Great for pasta, especially their Butternut Squash and Sage Butter Ravioli.
8 locals recommend
DOPO La Spiaggia
6 Bay Street(631) 725 - 7009. Great for pasta, especially their Butternut Squash and Sage Butter Ravioli.
(631) 800 - 8226. This restaurant offers specials that are excellent, and then various types of tacos and other items that are always fresh and go well with a glass of wine or a beer.
17 locals recommend
K Pasa
2 Main St(631) 800 - 8226. This restaurant offers specials that are excellent, and then various types of tacos and other items that are always fresh and go well with a glass of wine or a beer.
Sightseeing
This is a great place from which to rent bicycles. (631) 725 - 1110
19 locals recommend
Sag Harbor Cycle Company
34 Bay StThis is a great place from which to rent bicycles. (631) 725 - 1110
Good place to rent water sports items. (631) 680 - 0111.
6 locals recommend
Peconic Water Sports Sag Harbor
3253 Noyack RdGood place to rent water sports items. (631) 680 - 0111.
East End Explorer
1640 Conscience Point RoadThey rent paddle boards and kayaks, and conduct tours as well. (631) 353 - 5552.