Skip to content

Top restaurant recommendations from locals

American Restaurant
$$
“Enjoy a great meal overlooking Shinnecock Bay! Friendly staff and easy going atmosphere”
  • 70 locals recommend
Caribbean Restaurant
$$
“Take a complimentary boat ride between Rumba and Cowfish for a unique dining or drinking experience”
  • 52 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$$
“very nice sunsets...you can sit by the dock....cheap drinks on happy hours 3-6pm check their website.”
  • 32 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“Nice open bar,food so and so, live music... very nice sunsets and marina is worth a visit-free parking.-check the canal near by was man made in 1938 after Hurricane pushed ocean water over.”
  • 35 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Absolutely delicious food and a 1-minute walk from the property. Outdoor seating with a water view. ”
  • 24 locals recommend
Bar
$$$
“Fine dining in THE best restaurant on the South Fork. Excellent food and wonderful wines.”
  • 19 locals recommend
Cafe
$$
“Delicious low-key lunch and dinner, or just a lovely place to watch the sun set with a drink!”
  • 29 locals recommend
Breakfast Spot
$
“We've been going here for years and years. It's the quintessential destination for making your morning into a luxury vacation. Get there early for a table on the enclosed patio and enjoy the smell of fresh cut lawn and flowers along with your pancakes and bacon. Priced high but great value. Eggs Benedict are one of a kind!”
  • 18 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Enjoy some live music and fresh seafood while hanging on the beach with friends and family.”
  • 17 locals recommend
Meal Delivery
$$
“Sandwiches, pasta,prosciutto and more Italian specialties-take out or stay. ”
  • 19 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$$
“Not the best food but has the best view and location (right on the Ponguaque beach dunes). We recommend getting their oysters or mussels and a bottle of wine, and just stare out the windows. :)”
  • 9 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Casual restaurant serving specialty pizzas & Italian fare for dine-in, takeout or delivery.”
  • 10 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Italian restaurant and wine bar with a fresh new take on your old world favorites.”
  • 6 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Take out or stay if you really want but take out is better.Food is always fresh you can see live in aquariums what you will eat soon!”
  • 13 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Super casual take out with picnic tables and a killer fresh fish burrito plus much more, great burgers , quesadillas etc. Good for families with kids, there's a miniature golf course and surfbord sales and rentals out back.”
  • 7 locals recommend