Vacation rentals in Pickaway County

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Pickaway County

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A vibrant game room is highlighted by a red felt pool table centered on polished hardwood floors. A decorative light fixture hangs above the table, and a vintage-style fireplace adds character to the room. A doorway leads toward the staircase and the rest of the loft.

Apartment in Circleville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

The Happy Place, in historic uptown Circleville

Housed in the 1859 Jones Building, the Happy Place keeps the integrity of the original space with meaningful updates. High ceilings, original decorative fireplaces, newly refinished original hardwood floors and a billiards room. Located in historic uptown Circleville, just steps away from dining, the Ted Lewis Museum, Wittich's Candy Shop - the nation's oldest family owned and operated confectionary. 30 minutes to downtown Columbus and 30 minutes to the Hocking Hills and Deer Creek State Pk

Guest favorite

The historic Federal Style home features a classic red brick exterior, framed by tall windows with shutters. A covered entryway is accentuated by columns, and a well-maintained front garden is visible, showcasing neat shrubs and landscaping that enhance the inviting facade.

Townhouse in Circleville

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Charming Historic District 3-Bedroom Apartment

Bring the whole family to this Historic Home with lots of room to relax. This Federal Style home was built in 1835 and has three bedrooms, two baths, kitchen, dining room and living room. Features include hardwood floors, 12' ceilings and modern decor. Enjoy all that Circleville has to offer: within walking distance to Lindsey's Bakery, Wittich's Candy Shop, local restaurants & shopping. The dining room offers seating for everyone and the kitchen has everything you need for the family.

Superhost

A spacious living area offers high, vaulted ceilings adorned with wooden beams and a stone fireplace as a focal point. Large windows provide natural light and views of the surrounding greenery. Modern furniture, including a gray sectional sofa and accent chairs, creates a comfortable setting.

Cabin in Circleville

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Private Fun Barn~Hot Tub~Pool Table~Karaoke

Fun Barn NEW for 2025!!! Take a step of serenity into our Norwegian inspired Hocking Hills Lodge. Luxuriously designed and perfect for large families, friends, wedding parties, and even corporate retreats. Enjoy a campfire under the stars, relax in the oversized hot tub, or embrace your competitive side in the Fun Barn! Locally owned and available 24/7. Hocking Hills Hikes: Rockhouse: 14mi Cantwell Cliffs: 19mi Conkle's Hollow: 19mi Old Man's Cave: 22mi Support small businesses, Book Now!

Guest favorite

The front exterior of the cottage is seen, featuring a light-colored facade and large windows. A grassy lawn is surrounded by shrubs and trees, providing shade. A gravel path leads to the entrance, enhancing the welcoming appearance of the property.

Apartment in Circleville

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Roundtown Blue Cottage

Discover your perfect short-term rental on a tranquil street located on the north side of "The Roundtown" This updated 2-bedroom, 1-bath combines comfort with convenience. Within walking distance of the hospital, perfect for traveling hospital staff. Enjoy a spacious living area, a fully equipped kitchen, and work space, makes it great for families, friends, or business travelers. Just minutes from shops, and dining, this peaceful retreat offers everything you need for a relaxing stay.

Guest favorite

An open-concept living space features a comfortable sofa, a modern kitchen area with a large island and two stools, and a welcoming front entrance. Light wood accents and soft blue walls create a calm atmosphere, enhanced by natural light from windows.

Cottage in Circleville

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

The Cottage @ Tarlton's Edge

Take a break and unwind at this cozy 2bd 1 bath cottage getaway with a hot tub! Bedroom with King bed and closet Bedroom with Queen bed Covered front porch with glider. Back patio with table, hot tub and gas grill. Nice sized back yard with dire pit (roasting sticks and bag chairs in shed) Full-size washer/dryer. Large island, open concept. comfy sofa, table w/benches. Smart tv, wifi. Lancaster or Chillicothe less than 30 min drive, Circleville less than 15mins

Guest favorite

A rustic cabin is situated on a gentle slope, framed by trees at dusk. The structure features a stone chimney and large windows that softly illuminate the interior. The surrounding grass is well-kept, providing a serene environment.

Cabin in Laurelville

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Hot-Tub, Grill, Sunset Views, Firepit, Turntable

➤ Rustic Cabin: Secluded yet near the enchanting beauty of Hocking Hills. ➤ Sleeps 2 | 1 Loft Bedroom | 1 Bath ➤ Indoors: Fireplace, WiFi & Smart TV, Vinyl Record Player, Swing, Fully Equipped Kitchen ➤ Outdoor amenities: Hot tub, Charcoal Grill, Fire-pit, Swings, String lights, and Rocking chairs with sunset views. ➤ Located just 1-2 miles from convenience stores, grocery stores, and restaurants in Laurelville. ➤ Discounts on 3+ nights & Early Bird

Guest favorite

A modern kitchen area features a large island with seating for four and quartz countertops. Stainless steel appliances, including a microwave and refrigerator, are visible. A spiral staircase leads to the loft area, and natural light fills the space through large windows.

Religious building in Amanda

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Dragonfly Inn (Only 40 min to Hocking Hills area)

We love old churches & would rather repurpose than let them fall into disrepair, welcome to the Dragonfly! Two identical king en-suite bedrooms, & a loft with 6 extra long twin beds which could also be rearranged to make 3 kings. A half bath on the main floor. Minimum age to rent is 18. No pets. A rental agreement will need signed upon booking and a Refundable Damage Deposit of $300 will be charged to your credit card 3 days prior to arrival.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a tiny home is shown, featuring a stone facade and a central wooden front door. Two large windows flank the door, allowing natural light to enter. A concrete walkway leads up to the entrance, bordered by a neat lawn.

Tiny home in Harrisburg

5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Book your stay in our tiny home in a small village

This tiny home is anything but ordinary, truly one of a kind. Quiet village, easy access to 71/270. Close to Washington Courthouse, Grove City, Orient, Columbus, Commercial Point, London and Mount Sterling. This property is equipped with a full kitchen, washer and dryer, walk in shower, pull out murphy bed and a patio out back to relax. It is just a short drive from downtown Columbus. Perfect for a travel nurse or other traveling professional

Superhost

A brick carriage house features a distinctive steep roof and light green accents. A spacious paved area surrounds the entrance, which is flanked by expansive glass doors, allowing natural light to illuminate the interior. The setting presents a charming blend of architecture and outdoor space.

Guesthouse in Circleville

4.7 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

The Carriage House

The carriage house to a grand Victorian Mansion has been updated from stalls and lofts to a full one bedroom (two full pillowtop beds) one bathroom with large living room and kitchen on second floor....first floor available with notice for small gatherings for additional...Someday, the whole mansion will be available for weddings and events! This quaint town, mainstreet and exact home were once home to a Vaudeville star 100 years ago...

Superhost

An outdoor shelter features a spacious seating area illuminated by string lights, creating a cozy ambiance. Multiple wooden chairs and a table are arranged on a stone patio, alongside a grill and potted plants, providing a welcoming space for relaxation and gatherings.

Farm stay in Circleville

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Scippo Creek

Unique and peaceful country setting that is family and pet friendly. Firewood provided for an evening fire, alone with a full coffee bar If you would like to have the animal contact/experience please go to Scippo Creek Farm Stay and book your stay, the price difference includes time with the animals to soak up some love, learn about the animals and how they interact with each other and us. You can also feed and gather eggs, ect..

Guest favorite

A charming front porch features a hanging hammock swing softly illuminated by string lights. The entrance is framed by a welcoming white door adorned with a wreath, complemented by a doormat and potted plants on either side.

Home in Laurelville

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

The Laurelville House

Come stay with us for a peaceful getaway! The Laurelville house has all the amenities for you to have the best vacation. Located 8 1/2 miles from the Hocking Hills State Park and 10 miles from Tar Hollow State Park. It is also conveniently close to the grocery store, restaurants and coffee shops! Enjoy a fully stocked kitchen, games and puzzles, coffee on the front porch, a dip in the hot tub, and a latte from the coffee bar.

Superhost

A spacious living area features a warm wooden interior, highlighted by large windows that frame views of the surrounding trees. Comfortable leather seating includes a sofa and armchair, arranged on a patterned area rug, creating an inviting space for relaxation.

Cabin in Laurelville

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Dragonfly Cabin

Be the first to stay in this beautiful newly built Laurelville Cabin. Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room for fun. Short drive to Hocking Hills and all attractions associated with the famous Ohio landmark. Access private trails on this treed lot and perfect star gazing far from the busy city lights. Catch a glimpse of active wildlife and have fun exploring the local wilderness sites.