Vacation rentals in Old Fort Bay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Old Fort Bay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Home in Governor's Harbour

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Cayo Loco Beachfront Villa Deserted PinkSand for 2

S2E2 NETFLIX "WORLD'S MOST AMAZING VACATION RENTALS"! Beachfront villa right on deserted secluded pink sand beach! Watch dolphins with your coffee/coconut water/tarts! Beach toys included! Eleuthera means 'freedom'! Tranquil authentic tropical island paradise fusing eco design w/comfort! 1 of 2 brightly colored villas! Beach stroll to dining/bar/pool! Fish/surf/boat/dive/kayak/paddle board/relax! Unspoiled pristine oasis! 1 bed 1-1/2 bath 2 ADULTS ONLY! NO SMOKING/KIDS/LOUD MUSIC/VISITORS/FIRES!

Superhost

A wooden deck features a plunge pool surrounded by two loungers, creating a relaxing outdoor space. The setting is enhanced by a backdrop of trees and a vibrant sunset sky, casting warm colors over the scene.

Cottage in Rainbow Bay

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Villa Soreli - 1 B/R Oceanfront w/Pool

Villa Soreli, a brand new bespoke Ocean Front Luxury Villa rental in Rainbow Bay, Eleuthera Bahamas (NOT NASSAU). This 1 B/R private villa includes a Queen-sized Master bedroom with an additional King-size Sleeper Sofa to accommodate a family of 4. Our villa is fully equipped with a full kitchen, indoor & outdoor shower, high end finishes & a plunge pool overlooking the Caribbean Sea. It is walking distance to Rainbow Bay Beach. Nestled in between the Caribbean Sea and the Atlantic Ocean.

Top guest favorite

A serene beachfront scene reveals gentle waves lapping against the shore, with a wooden swing set positioned on the sand, framed by vibrant green grass and palm foliage. The clear blue sky complements the tranquil turquoise waters in the background.

Home in Spanish Wells

5 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Cottage GEAUX FISH Spanish Wells Kayak Lush Garden

GEAUX FISH is remodeled and available as a fully furnished vacation rental in Western View and steps from the calm water at Abner’s Pavilion. New beach swings are a short walk from our front door. 1 bedroom 2 full baths. Double kayak, grill, outdoor shower, snorkel, beach gear. Sleeps 4. 250 GALLON BACKUP WATER SYSTEM!!! Our caretakers are nearby if needed. We can help with golf cart, excursions, boat rental, and transportation from our local airport. FREE GIFT with each stay! Thank You Lord!

Guest favorite

Cottage in Hatchet Bay

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Extraordinary Oceanfront Peninsula. Walk to Beach.

*Low $65 cleaning fee. No other host fees. *Superhosts since 2016. Over 1000 reviews on Airbnb - 4.95 star average. *Discount SUV rental and adventure tours such as the swimming pigs. *3 minute walk to beaches, bars, restaurants, great central location. *Superb snorkeling and fishing right at our property. *Incredible oceans views of the Caribbean on all sides. *Unique 3 sided peninsula allows for both sunrises and sunsets. *Eagle Rays swim by the deck every day as part of their routine.

Guest favorite

An inviting outdoor area is showcased with a large pool surrounded by lush tropical plants. Comfortable seating is arranged nearby, and a shaded patio awaits for relaxation. The house features multiple windows, allowing natural light to illuminate the space.

Home in New Providence

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Hightides

This stunning large home has everything a traveling family needs for an amazing luxury vacation, nestled on a cul de sac in a safe upscale neighborhood. 10 min walking distance to 2 popular beaches and a (3rd) small private beach that is perfect for morning and evening walks where the sunset is spectacular. Take phone calls from the covered outdoor living space while you watch your kids swim in a beautiful pool. We recommend renting a car to travel to Grocery stores 10 minute drive.

Guest favorite

An aerial view captures a beachfront property bordered by lush greenery and gently swaying palm trees. The sandy shore meets clear waters, while the home features a modest roof and outdoor spaces for relaxation. Nearby, a pathway leads from the house to the beach.

Vacation home in Nassau

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

Breathtaking seaside vista, secluded escape

Steps from the sea, 200 feet of beachfront escape to your own paradise getaway for you and your family or small party. Private and secluded area in historic Adelaide village. Close to airport, and Bahamar resort for entertainment and dining. Clear aquamarine waters shallow and safe for children. Relax with you own slice of the Caribbean in this peaceful place to stay. Blackout drapes/curtains. You will be looking forward to returning again. 2 bedrooms and a sleeper sofa.

Guest favorite

A serene beach scene is captured with smooth sand leading to calm waters. Gentle waves reflect sunlight, creating a shimmering effect. Lush greenery is visible on the right, while rocky formations frame the foreground, providing a natural boundary to the sandy shoreline.

Home in Current

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Bertrams Cove

This rental home is located in the quaint and quiet settlement of The Current, Eleuthera. Beautifully situated on the North Beach, you have direct access to the beach, your own piece of paradise. This home is centrally air-conditioned, has wifi and cable tv. A smart tv which also allows you to connect to Netflix. The kitchen is fully stocked with everything you need to feel right at home when preparing meals. There is also a charcoal grill.

Superhost

A airy and light-filled space is showcased, featuring large screens that provide views of the lush greenery outside. A simple kitchen area is visible, with a sink and countertop adorned with seashells and a small blue bowl. Several white chairs surround a round table.

Apartment in Governor's Harbour

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Casuarina Bay sunset apartment

Dolphin Doon’s enchanting sunset apartment is just steps from the very private sandy beach of Casuarina bay. Charmingly decorated with island furnishings and full of natural light, this studio is perfect for 2 guests. This bright and airy new space (completed November 2019) features a large sleeping area with queen bed and five picture windows facing west to capture the beautiful Bahamian sunsets.

Guest favorite

A modern kitchen and dining area are presented with sleek white cabinetry and a black refrigerator. A dining table with four chairs is centered, and a comfortable seating area features a blue sofa. Light reflects off the glossy floor, enhancing the spacious layout.

Apartment in Governor's Harbour

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Bird Cage Rental

Discover the perfect escape at our cozy and peaceful 1-bedroom Airbnb. Nestled in the heart of Governor’s Harbour, this charming retreat is your home away from home. Unwind in comfort, and soak in the tranquility of this inviting space. Whether you're here for a romantic getaway or a family adventure, our Airbnb is your haven of relaxation. Book your stay now and create unforgettable memories!

Guest favorite

A two-story home features a welcoming entrance with a wooden door under a covered porch. Large windows allow natural light, while landscaped greenery and colorful plants frame the exterior. A clear walkway leads to the house, complemented by a driveway and outdoor air conditioning units.

Apartment in Nassau

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Williams Cozy Nest Conveniently Located!

Bring your family to a home away from home. Spacious 2BD 2.5BATH home to enjoy your vacation in a clean and safe environment. Close to airport, beaches and shops. Lake views from both bedrooms. Gated community that has a Kids playground, basketball court, 24hr security. NO smoking of any sort is permitted inside of unit.

Superhost

Home in Spanish Wells

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Summer Sunset/On The Beach/New 2015

Property is right on the stunning white sand beach of Spanish Wells. Centrally located but in a very quiet peaceful location. Best rental location on island. Shops and restaurants all within a mile and easy access with the FREE Golfcart provided. Island settled by English Europeans in 1600s