Vacation rentals in New Jerusalem

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Jerusalem

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Cottage in Huntsville

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

❤️ Waddle Inn ❤️ Luxury Cottage on Tecumseh Island

Quiet & Cozy Lake House Cottage on Tecumseh Island! Perfect get away for couples/families. Amazing Location w/ surrounding lake views! Beautiful remodel, stylish decor. 2 Bedrooms, Sleeps up to 7. Granite counters, recessed lighting, gas burning fireplace. Open the windows to enjoy the nice lake breeze. Amenities include sleeper sectional, 4K HD TV w ROKU & Chromecast, High-Speed Internet, Keurig Coffee Maker w/ complimentary coffee, microwave, refrigerator, oven/stove, fully furnished kitchen.

Jan 9 – 16

G$22,348 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Tiny home in Zanesfield

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Hilltop Hide-Away

Hilltop Hide-Away is nestled on top of Mad River Mountain. You can walk/ski right to the lift; directly from the property, during the winter. Hiking on the mountain is always fun in the summer months. Enjoy horseback riding? You are minutes away from Marmon Valley Horse Farm! If exploring is your thing...check out the Ohio Caverns just a few miles down the road. Downtown Bellefontaine is only ten minutes away with lots to offer such as, great eateries, one-of-a-kind shops and boutiques.

Oct 7 – 14

G$38,889 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Apartment in Urbana

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

Downtown Historic Dist. Walk to Dining & Shops.

Relax while working or work on relaxing. The Kenton Suite is perfect. Located in the heart of historic downtown Urbana. Restaurants, antique shops, theater, and boutiques are all within easy walking distance. Our Kenton Suite apartment is beautifully decorated and comfortable for a weekend or an extended stay. Private entrance gives you the flexibility to come and go as you please. Fast Wifi for work. Semi private veranda right outside your door for enjoying the view of the beautiful yard.

Jan 3 – 10

G$26,897 GYD per night

Superhost

Tiny home in Zanesfield

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Delightful tiny house located on 110 wooded acres

With miles of wooded trails right outside your doorstep, this tiny house getaway is the perfect retreat. You'll be suprised how spacious it feels, as this cozy tiny is just right for two. There is a firepit out back and over 100 acres to explore. All of your basic amenities are provided, so come ready to relax and enjoy some downtime in nature! More adventure is nearby, as Mad River Mountain and Marmon Valley Farm are 5 minutes away and the cute town of Bellefontaine is within 12 minutes.

Aug 15 – 22

G$21,910 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Apartment in Irwin

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 335 reviews

Rosedale Retreat

We live on a two acre lot near Rosedale Bible College in central Ohio. The apartment is a cozy, private, single bedroom apartment attached to our home on the ground level. Space includes a 3 season room, kitchen, living room, bathroom, laundry room, patio with picnic table, and a large yard. Breakfast items are provided. There is a beautiful nature/walking trail next to the property. In 35 minutes, you can be on The Ohio State University campus as well as the Columbus Zoo and Aquarium.

Oct 12 – 19

G$14,195 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Kenton

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Sophia's Country Cottage - R&R, Quiet & Peaceful

Lovely private attached bungalow style suite. Single story privacy (no floors above or below). We offer a cozy spacious suite for you to relax and enjoy the beautiful outdoors. Private driveway/parking (not ideal for big rigs) with motion activated lights to guide you. Private back porch with access to the fire pit. Key-free entrance. Private laundry & bathroom. Enjoy everything Hardin County has to offer. Located 10 minutes from the Hardin County Armory wedding venue.

Aug 18 – 25

G$14,840 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Farm stay in Ottawa

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 164 reviews

The Granary

The Granary at Pierman Homestead farm is a unique and spacious home. Set on a small farm in the country, the it was converted from barn to cottage in the late 1990's. The home overlooks a farm pond and grazing pasture. Pets are allowed (for fee) and our dog and cats may stop by to visit. Great for families coming home to visit, or looking for a place to get away. Great for travelers visiting the Gilboa Quarry. Parties and events are “not allowed” per AirBNB policy.

Sep 25 – Oct 2

G$24,819 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Marengo

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews

Adorable 1-bedroom guest house on small horse farm

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Explore the grounds, relax by the pond, hangout in front of a backyard fire, or stay inside and watch a movie or play a board game. Bedroom has a queen bed, and sofa in livingroom as a pull-out queen bed. 12 min from the Morrow County Fairgrounds. 8 min to Cardinal Shooting Center. 30 min to Columbus, and 38 min to John Glenn International Airport. No pets allowed. There are currently no horses living on the farm.

Feb 17 – 24

G$17,772 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cabin in Urbana

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 715 reviews

The Cabin at Maple View - Accepting Reservations

We are open for guests! The Cabin at Maple View is located a quarter mile off of the highway down a long twisting driveway. It is tucked back in the woods and away from it all. You notice the Amish craftsmanship as soon as you arrive. You are surrounded by 80 acres of manicured woods and a huge yard. The environment is welcoming. The atmosphere is warm. Call it your home for a night or for an extended stay. It is beautiful no matter the time of year.

Feb 8 – 15

G$23,557 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cottage in Lakeview

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

The Cottage at Indian Lake

Our place is located on a channel with easy access to the main lake, many restaurants and Old Field Beach. You’ll love our place because of the location, cottage feel, fenced in yard with a stamped concrete patio and fire pit. Kayaks, outdoor dining set, fire pit utensils, Blackstone griddle and Culligan water. While we do have well water, we also had a new water softener and water heater installed in 2022.

Apr 8 – 15

G$28,217 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Farm stay in Plain City

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 666 reviews

Countryside Private Dwelling

Enjoy the peaceful countryside just 15 minutes off of the outer loop of Columbus. We have a seperate guest house on our small farm with a king size master suite and queen bedroom. This guest home is completely private from the main residence and is the perfect ambience for peace and quiet. . My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids), and big groups.

Dec 2 – 9

G$21,113 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cabin in Conover

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 301 reviews

Scenic Grace Cabin- Peaceful & Wooded Lake View

Nestled behind Kiser Lake, in a peaceful and wooded setting, is Scenic Grace Cabin. You are welcomed with your own private drive that leads you to a picturesque cabin, filled with all the amenities that you will need during your stay, including a new hot tub. The neighborhood is peaceful and quiet, and you can enjoy all that Kiser Lake State Park has to offer.

Mar 27 – Apr 3

G$34,816 GYD per night