Vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
An open living area is highlighted by a large, comfortable sectional sofa positioned on a patterned rug. Exposed wooden beams adorn the ceiling, adding warmth. A stone fireplace and large windows provide natural light, while views of the outdoor deck and wooded surroundings can be seen.
Home in Harrisburg
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 333 reviews

Home away from home

Open floor plan on a wooded lot. 3 bedrooms, two bathrooms, kitchen, great room. Large deck over looks the yard and into the woods where the deer like to play. Close to Hershey, Lancaster and Gettysburg. Great places to eat within minutes. Queit neighborhood with some great views if your in the mood for a walk. Apartment on the bottom floor is occupied by my son and his cat while he attends PennState. He has separate parking and entrance. The only interaction with keegan would be if asked

Top guest favorite
Cabin in Jonestown
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Tobias Cabin

This peaceful and centrally located cabin provides tranquility and relaxation in the Blue Mountains. The large wraparound porch surrounded by the lush landscape and natural beauty of the cold spring, creates an environment that you don’t want to miss. Spend your evening looking up at the stars in the hot tub or making s’mores over a fire creating lasting memories. If you choose to be adventurous there is hiking trails, biking, fishing, kayaking and several state parks with lakes nearby. Enjoy!

Top guest favorite
Place to stay in Shippensburg
5 out of 5 average rating, 460 reviews

The Frame ~ Charming Nature Escape ~ Hot Tub ~ BBQ

Escape to the charming 2BR 1Bath A-frame on a secluded wooded property just 10 mins away from Shippensburg, PA. Whether you're looking to savor nature‘s tranquility from the luxurious hot tub, share stories around the fire pit, or explore picturesque Cumberland Valley, this will be the ideal starting point for your adventures. *2 Comfortable BRs *Open Design Living *Full Kitchen *Smart TV *Backyard (Hot Tub, Sauna, Fire Pit, BBQ, Outdoor shower) *High-Speed Wi-Fi *Free Parking *EV charger

Top guest favorite
The ranch-style home features a welcoming front porch with three chairs, surrounded by a neatly maintained lawn. The driveway leads to a gravel path and two garages. Lush greenery and trees provide a serene backdrop to the property, enhancing the secluded atmosphere.
Home in Halifax
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 211 reviews

Peaceful Getaway, with hot tub & fire pit.

Escape to Peaceful Getaway, where cozy comfort meets countryside charm. Nestled among the trees, this home invites you to slow down and enjoy life’s simple moments. Sip morning coffee on the deck as birds sing, spend the day exploring Lake Tobias or hiking the Appalachian Trail, then unwind in the hot tub or make s’mores by the fire pit under the stars. Whether for a romantic escape or family adventure, Peaceful Getaway offers the perfect blend of relaxation and connection.

Top guest favorite
A modern cottage is nestled among trees, featuring a white exterior and contrasting dark roof. An outdoor patio with string lights provides a seating area, surrounded by natural stone landscaping and large rocks. The inviting structure exudes a serene charm, perfect for relaxation.
Home in Newport
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 445 reviews

Long Acre Farm Stay! Find seclusion on the back 40

Hi! Long Acre Hideaway is a secluded cottage dedicated to providing a quiet place for couples and/or small families to spend quality time with each other and with God. Come to the “back 40” of the farm to relax and rejuvenate! Experience some of the area’s best views on the walk around the perimeter of the farm on a 1.8 mile marked trail! Rest on the deck with a cup of coffee and watch for wildlife or soak in the private hot tub at night and watch the stars!

Top guest favorite
The GeoDome is showcased from an exterior angle, highlighting its unique geodesic structure. Large clear panels reveal a cozy interior with a spacious bed and wooden flooring. The surrounding grassy area and evening sky suggest a serene outdoor setting.
Dome in Millerstown
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 222 reviews

GeoDome in the Country

This unique GeoDome is perfect for a cozy stay with your favorite person or as a relaxing getaway by yourself. Located in the peaceful countryside on the farm estate of The Homestead on Peanut Road. Few neighbors and an open sky create a perfect environment for star-gazing on clear evenings. Our dome is located on the edge of our family farm property across from the main Farm House. Enjoy an evening fire at the fire pit located just beside the GeoDome.

Top guest favorite
A bright and airy living space features large windows that fill the room with natural light. Comfortable seating includes a sleek black chair, a cozy armchair, and a leather couch. A decorative rug anchors the space, complemented by greenery near the windows.
Home in Liverpool
5 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

Hot tub, Pond, & Firepit on 8 acres!

Escape to this serene outback gem, ideal for couples, small families, or a group of friends looking for a peaceful retreat. ★ Enjoy breathtaking views of the night sky ★ Gather around the firepit near the pond for cozy evenings. ★ Explore 8 acres of natural beauty, complete with a stream and pond. ★ Meet our charming farm animals. ★ Ideal for personal reflection, family bonding, or quality time. This is the perfect spot to get away, reflect, and ponder.

Guest favorite
Home in Harrisburg
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 662 reviews

Walk to Midtown From Contemporary Uptown Harrisburg Home

Beautifully remodeled, single family, brick rowhome in the "Olde Uptown" neighborhood of Harrisburg. Take advantage of the extra care and personal touches in this property such as complimentary beverages and snacks, continental breakfast items, professionally designed interior, and incredibly comfortable king sized bed. You can walk to the fantastic Broad Street Market, local coffee shop and cafe, and the beautiful riverfront trail.

Top guest favorite
Cabin in Newport
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 344 reviews

A-Frame W/ HOTTub, MountainView,Pickleball/tennis

Welcome to Hilltop Haven A-Frame. Perched on top of the ridge and surrounded by trees, this unique getaway offers breathtaking views, total privacy, and a true connection to nature. Designed for both relaxation and recreation, this home has something for everyone—whether you’re unwinding in the hot tub, gathering around the fireplace, or enjoying a friendly competition outdoors.

Top guest favorite
A charming cottage is nestled among trees, featuring a stone exterior and large windows that provide a view of the surrounding woods. A gravel path leads to the entrance, while a spacious yard is seen in front, enhancing the serene setting.
Cottage in Mifflinburg
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 229 reviews

Cozy Pines *Sweetheart* Cottage

Enjoy a romantic vacation at this beautiful little cottage tucked away in the woods. No TV means you can enjoy the surrounding nature and your loved one. Deer, raccoons, and foxes share the spacious front yard. Take a walk along a tributary of Buffalo Creek as it meanders through the woods, or relax and take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a two-story cabin is highlighted, featuring a light-colored facade with a gabled roof. A welcoming front porch includes two rocking chairs. The surrounding area is lush with greenery, emphasizing a connection to nature and tranquility in the setting.
Cabin in Landisburg
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 340 reviews

Cozy Ridge Cottage

Relax and reconnect with the whole family at this peaceful place. Or spend a wonderful time with your special person. Enjoy the sights and sounds of nature, and a beautiful view of the mountains. Our modern/boho cabin sleeps 6 guests, and offers the common necessities you will need on you’re stay with a few little extras along the way.

Guest favorite
A cozy deck area is shown, complete with two dark wicker chairs and a small table. A wooden railing surrounds the space, providing a feeling of privacy. Natural light illuminates the inviting area, with greenery visible in the background.
Guesthouse in Harrisburg
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 217 reviews

The Treehouse at Fort Hunter Park

Next to historic Fort Hunter Park and on the riverbank of the Susquehanna, the Treehouse is a cozy getaway only 5 minutes from center city Harrisburg. Walk in the park, ride our bikes, paddle the river in our kayaks, fish or just chill and read on our riverdecks and furniture.....

Popular amenities for New Buffalo vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Pennsylvania
  4. Perry County
  5. New Buffalo