Vacation rentals in Fiddle Cay

Harbourside Hideaway

You'll love this unique and romantic escape located in the heart of New Plymouth in Green Turtle Cay. Tucked away on the front street, with beautiful views of the harbour, Harbour Hideaway is a 2 minute walk away from the ferry dock and steps away from all local conveniences-- bars, restaurants, food stores, coffee shops and bakeries. Perfect for singles, couples or a small group. Newly renovated with modern furnishings and amenities, this studio unit is perfect for your visit to beautiful GTC!

Blair's Bungalow - 2bdr. Green Turtle Cay/Dock

Blair’s Bungalow is a bright, spacious 2-bed/1 bath half of a duplex on our peaceful Black Sound property. Guests enjoy access to a private dock & boat slip—perfect for exploring the islands. With a well-appointed eat-in kitchen, flexible bedroom setups (king or XL twins) an open, inviting layout, it’s ideal for couples, families, or friends seeking comfort, convenience. Come stay with us and you'll see why guests consistently give high ratings to Blair's Bungalow and return year after year.

Castaway Cove Beach Villa

Castaway Cove is a freshly renovated, cozy villa new on the rental market just steps from Treasure Cay's beautiful 3 1/2 mile long beach. Peaceful and tranquil, yet you can walk to the pool, store, and blissful beachfront dining. The villa is fully equipped with all of the creature comforts you're used to at home, but feels a world away. Laze about sipping on cocktails right here, take a day trip around Abaco, or ferry to one of the many nearby islands for adventure. Paradise awaits you!

Blue Wave Dreamin' Ocean Villas

Blue Wave Dreamin’ Ocean Villa 920 is a bright & airy 2 bdrm/2 bth villa, built & furnished in Jan 2023, floor to ceiling windows & sliding glass doors surround the open concept kitchen & living area, on the swimming pool & green area, 40 yards from beach, adjacent to the Marina. Decorated in blues & greens of Bahamian waters & grey tones of driftwood. In the boutique community of Ocean Villas situated on Treasure Cay beach ranked by National Geographic in the Top 10 beaches in the World.

Bahamian Pine - Modern Beach Villa

Discover Bahamian Pine, renovated Villa 583 offering a modern beach vibe in The Beach Villa's of Treasure Cay, Abaco. This crisp, clean oasis boasts quality furnishings, a fully equipped kitchen with high-end appliances, and a screened-in dining area. Step outside to find an outdoor shower and a cozy fire pit. Steps to the pool and the beach. Our tranquil retreat is perfect for couples or small families. Let us introduce you to the laid-back, barefoot beach lifestyle. Welcome to paradise!

5 Bedroom Island Hideaway – Fish, Snorkel, Unwind

Adventure awaits at our secluded 5-bedroom, 3-bath (4 bedrooms inside, 1 detached bunk house room) waterfront home on the Sea of Abaco! Swim, fish, snorkel, and explore hidden beaches just minutes from your door. Located only 15 minutes from Treasure Cay, this private island retreat is the perfect base for island hopping, fishing excursions, and outdoor fun. Wake up to stunning sea views and spend your days discovering all the Abacos have to offer. Your island adventure starts here!

Maranatha Cottage, Green Turtle Cay - Harbour View

Bright, breezy, coastal cottage located in the main village of New Plymouth. Originally built in the late 1860s but completely renovated and modern. Situated on the main shore road with a view of the beautiful harbour. Minutes away from restaurants, grocery stores and the beaches. Air conditioned throughout, main bed and bath downstairs, second bedroom (twin beds, air mattress or convertible to a King upon request.) with full shower and bathroom upstairs.

Lillian's Bungalows - Ground Floor Retreat

Welcome to the Ground Floor Retreat—a spacious, self-contained unit built with professional expertise and designed for total guest comfort. Located in peaceful Green Turtle Estates, you are just steps from spectacular Ocean Beach and a short golf cart ride from the calmer waters of Coco Bay. Enjoy direct access to the private patio and lawn, making island living easy and accessible. Note: This listing is for the Downstairs Unit ONLY.

Beachside Escape~Ocean Front~Steps To The Beach

Welcome to Beachside Escape, a stunning retreat situated in the private Ocean Villas community of Treasure Cay. Immerse yourself in the beauty of the Sea of Abaco, with exceptional views of tranquil turquoise waters, soothing sunsets and a pristine white sand beach. Forget your worries and enjoy the laid-back, barefoot lifestyle of The Bahamas!

Near Green Turtle Marina [3 king Bedrm w 3.5 Bath]

Tucked away in a tropical garden, Pirates Rest has glimpse of Coco Bay and White Sound from the second floor. It's a short walk to Green Turtle Club and Marina (convenient store, gas pump, gift shop, restaurant and bar.) Three large master bedrooms all with their own ensuite bathroom. Each room equipped with king bed, luxury sheets and towels.

Secluded Contemporary 2BR 2BA Suite

Emerald Suite - Experience a true hidden gem with modern finishes and spacious living. This secluded retreat features 2 baths and comes fully loaded with top-of-the-line appliances. Each room boasts a TV for your entertainment. Located on a hill, it offers the tranquility of a private getaway and is only 7 minutes away from the main airport.

Rest Easy Nightly Rental

Enjoy easy access to everything from this perfectly located nightly room rental. A one minute walk from Baker's Bay dock. A two minutes drive from the center of town and the food store. A five minutes ride from the Marsh Harbour Airport. A minute walk from the conch stand and restaurant.