Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Erie County

We had a wonderful stay at Cheryl’s cottage. It was very homey. Immaculately cleaned. Great decoration. Very comfortable. A very peaceful place to be. Cheryl was extremely responsive and helpful. Excellent host.

This was our fourth year staying at Barbara's and the place has now become as familiar to us as a second home. We again enjoyed our long weekend and expect to return next March. The lodge is cozy, well maintained and has all the attributes to make your stay enjoyable and relaxing. Thanks Barbara.

This was our second time staying here and we’ll stay again! The home is comfortable and cozy, as well as a great location for fishing. Stocked with everything you need, plus more! Laura is a great host and responds promptly. Thanks for having our family again, Laura. We hope to be back again!

This was a perfect location and set up for our crazy weekend! Everything we needed was available! And the comfy couches made for a perfect place to wait out the rain delays of the soccer tournament! Thanks so much!! Allison

The home was beautifully decorated (could be in magazine) and pristine clean. It was a great size for a group of 8 people- the lounge area, dining room and deck were larger areas where we could all comfortably spend quality family time together. There was enough driveway and garage parking for all of our cars. We also enjoyed making a fire in the firepit. The hosts were super responsive and gave good recommendations. Looks like the pictures. We would definitely come back.

We really enjoyed our stay at Kristi’s home. It was very peaceful and private and our dogs really enjoyed playing outside.

Our grandchildren (3 & 5) loved playing in the creek. This property is right on the lake with a gorgeous panoramic view & lovely sunsets. There’s a nice swimming area with a lifeguard just down the road . If you want to walk on the beach and/or swim, water shoes are a must.

Troy was an excellent communicator. We loved how the backyard opened right on to Lake Erie. Big back porch for enjoying sunsets! Plenty of linens. Very clean.

it was a lovely apt. and very clean. I will stay aging on my next trip north. I wanted ac and it ended up being chilly, but the apt was warm and very cozy.

Don was great company and does a great job at taking care of any needs. Great atmosphere and sceneries. I would definitely recommend this place if you are looking for a nice quiet place with great company.

My husband and I enjoyed our time here. It is a great location for all activities in the Lake Erie and surrounding area. Very comfortable house and lovely setting.

This was my second stay at this property. I found it peaceful and the neighborhood very walkable. A few minutes walk to the park and also walkable to main streets with amenities. The place is nicely decorated and hosts were very responsive.

Although the address is on a busy street, the adjoining house blocks almost all road noise. It was a quiet and restful location. Would stay here again when in the area.

We spent the long weekend here, and we’re really pleased with our stay! It was easy to find, and great for the time we were there. There is a bit of noise at night from the road and people outside. If you have neighbors in the next apartment, they can be heard as well, but it wasn’t a huge deal. Overall had a pleasant experience here!

Very nice place to stay! Pretty, clean, great view of the lake, with everything you need for a comfortable stay. Also, the host is very responsive by email — I had a question while trying to find the place, and when I emailed Ingrid she popped right out and showed me where to go. Definitely recommend.

We couldn’t have planned a better weekend getaway. The grounds were beautiful. The cabin was clean and comfortable. Leigh and Matt are friendly and accommodating hosts who wanted us to have the best experience they could offer and they met every expectation we could have imagined. We will be recommending Bison Trace to all of our friends!! Thank you for a great weekend!!

We had a wonderful stay at this cozy cabin! It was the perfect home base for our family during a busy weekend of soccer tournament games. My husband, our two kids, and my sister all felt right at home — there was plenty of space for everyone to relax between matches. The cabin was clean, comfortable, and had everything we needed. The peaceful setting was a nice contrast to the hustle of the tournament, and we appreciated being close enough to come and go easily. The hosts were thoughtful and responsive, which made the experience even smoother. We’d definitely stay here again — it made our weekend so much more enjoyable and stress-free!

What a beautiful place in an inconspicuous place. Little oasis. What a gem. Went to sing and did.

Nice cabin. Can see the lake.. had A little trouble getting in and out with all the snow , in my van.. And could’ve used a light over the dining table to do some paperwork, they have several lights everywhere else which is nice except there, or anywhere else to do paperwork, a desk or etc. I love all the wood. The furniture was nice. Thanks.

We booked a last minute mini vacation for my husband and I, our 9 year old daughter and 18 month baby boy. At the last minute our 13 year old niece needed a ride to the same area to visit her grandma so she tagged along as well. But once we were to this great little cabin we find out her grandmother broke her hand and wasn’t up for the company so our niece stayed with us for the 4 days we were there. The cabin was great! It had just enough room for the 5 of us. The cabin was baby proof as we definitely needed for our lil man. It was clean and had everything we needed to make our stay comfortable. Lynn and Mac were right down the road if we needed anything and they made suggestions for things to do with the kids. It was so peaceful with the fire place. We were able to have drinks in the evening and relax and during the day were close enough to Erie and the beaches that the kids were never bored. I highly recommend this home away from home and can’t wait to visit again! Loved it!😍

Fabulous stay in Gray Birch! They really thought of everything! We didn't need many of the amenities during our short stay, but the kitchen was very well-provisioned for eating-in and all the spaces had thoughtful touches. I loved the cozy lantern lights in the bedroom and the lantern and headlamps by the door, and there was even a spot to hang the lantern by the picnic table and fire pit. I wondered if it might be a little loud with other "campers" nearby, but it was very quiet during our stay. My favorite part was sitting on the screened in porch in the morning and evening, enjoying the peaceful surroundings. The ceiling fan on the porch was just perfect on a humid night. Sadly, we didn't have time to make a fire during our short stay, but the picnic table, grill, fire pit and Adirondack chairs looked great. Several of the cabins have the fire pit on the side of the cabin, but I Iiked that Gray Birch's was in the front (if you park at the back).

My girlfriend and I stayed one night in Cabin #3 at Edinboro Lake Resort, and it was absolutely perfect. From the moment we arrived, everything was effortless—check-in couldn’t have been easier. The key was waiting for us inside the cabin, which made settling in seamless and stress-free after a long drive. The cabin itself was spotless and incredibly comfortable. You can tell it’s well cared for—clean linens, cozy furniture, and everything we needed was right there. It had a warm, inviting feel that made us instantly relax and enjoy the peaceful surroundings. It was the ideal setting for a quiet getaway, and we only wish we had stayed longer. We’ll definitely be back—and next time, for more than just one night!

We had a great stay! The pond was so peaceful! We loved listening to the frogs and watching the beaver while we had a bon fire!